The 14 Best Store-Bought Chocolate Chip Cookies That Deserve an Extra Large Glass of Milk

Was there anything better than coming home from a hard day at school to find fresh, homemade cookies still warm from the oven? Peanut butter, shortbread, and sugar cookies were all pretty good, but nothing beat chocolate chip.

You would sit down with a glass of cold milk and bite into the warm, chewy cookie, taking the time to lick the molten chocolate chips from your fingers. Once you were done, you were convinced you had just eaten the world’s best chocolate chip cookie, and you couldn’t feel more loved if you tried.

But what if you can’t find your childhood cookie recipe or don’t have time to bake? Good news! Some of the best store-bought chocolate chip cookies are indistinguishable from homemade. And you don’t have to settle for dry, crumbly biscuits either. Packaged chocolate chip cookies come in a variety of forms. Some bakers shake things up by using different types of chocolate chips like milk or Belgian chocolate. Others taste as good as if they came from your local bakery. Are chewy cookies your jam? You can find some of the best soft chocolate chip cookies right on your grocery store shelf. 

Ready to indulge in some childhood nostalgia? Pull up a chair, pour yourself a tall glass of milk, and prepare to taste some of the best chocolate chip cookie brands you can buy. Oh! And don’t forget to call your favorite childhood baker and ask for their chocolate chip cookie recipe.

1. Nunbelievable Chocolate Chip Artisanal Cookie

Grab a big glass of milk, enjoy a yummy cookie and do some good at the same time. For every cookie purchased, Nunbelievable donates a meal to someone in need. These are non-GMO, free of preservatives and artificial flavors, with chocolate chip deliciousness packed into one virtuous cookie. It doesn’t get better than this.

2. Tate’s Bake Shop Chocolate Chip Cookies

This is the cookie that put Tate’s Bake Shop on the map! Their chocolate chip cookies are uniquely thin, crispy, and deeply delicious. Rich in buttery flavor, these treats are packed with chocolate chips and pecans, making for a toothsome snack. They’re great for sharing, but we think you’ll want to keep them to yourself.

3. Partake Gluten-Free Vegan Crunchy Chocolate Chip Cookies

The icon. The classic. The chocolate chip cookie you can feel good about sharing. It’s a treat that ticks all the boxes: gluten-free, vegan, top 8 allergen-free, non-GMO, and kosher. It’s a delicious crunchy cookie made for the masses. 

4. Grandma’s Big Chocolate Chip Cookie

Grandma’s Big Chocolate Chip Cookies are a soft and sweet snack for any time of day. These chewy chocolate chip cookies are soft, sweet, and loaded with all the chips you could hope for. Bring the taste of fresh-baked cookies home from the store — there’s nothing better than cookies from Grandma.

5. Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Chocolate Chip Cookies

Pepperidge Farm Chocolate Chip Cookies are perfectly baked with real ingredients. Rich chocolate, creamery butter, eggs, and vanilla extract come together to craft perfect thin and crispy cookies that melt in your mouth. The only thing these cookies need is a big glass of milk.

6. Lenny & Larry’s The Complete Chocolate Chip Cookie

These chocolate chip cookies complete your life. Lenny & Larry have baked a chewy, soft cookie loaded with protein, healthy fiber, and zero guilt. These delectable chocolate chip cookies are vegan, non-GMO, and free of high fructose corn syrup and artificial sweeteners. It’s the perfect no-worry treat.

7. Made Good Organic Chocolate Chip Soft Baked Mini Cookies

This is an ode to the world’s most beloved cookie. Soft, chewy, and chocolatey, these are the perfect little cookies. Vegan dark chocolate chips give a burst of extra flavor. Like all MadeGood products, this cookie is safe for school lunches — they’re low sugar, vegan, and gluten-free. Just sit and enjoy!

8. Steve & Andy’s Chocolate Chip Cookies

When it comes to making downright delicious cookies, Steve and Andy know exactly what they’re doing. They use organic molasses that bake up deliciously crispy cookies with a caramelized flavor you won’t get enough of. Even better, they contain no GMOs, nuts, or gluten, so dive in.

9. Chips Ahoy! Original Chocolate Chip Cookies

The classic cookie you’ve come to know and love. Chips Ahoy! Original Chocolate Chip Cookies are baked to perfection every time with a crunch that satisfies even the most demanding sweet tooth. Don’t forget to add milk to your order for dunking.

10. Crust Bakery Chocolate Chip Cookie

The classic chocolate chip cookie has gone vegan with fair-trade chocolate chips. The delicious chocolate flavor bursts through with every bite. Crust is a women-owned and -operated, all-natural, all-vegan bakery serving delicious baked goods throughout Philadelphia.

11. Keebler Chips Deluxe Original

Keebler’s signature extra-thick cookies are stuffed with tons of genuine chocolate chips. Baked to crispy perfection, these are a classic treat that’ll please the entire family. A truly original creation that only the Keebler Elves could pull off.

12. Famous Amos Belgian Chocolate Chip Cookies

Famous Amos delivers exquisite international flavor in a crunchy bite-sized treat. The classic chocolate chip cookie you love gets an upgrade with a delectable contribution from Belgium — home of the world’s finest chocolate.

13. Pamela’s Gluten-Free Chunky Chocolate Chip Cookies

A favorite since 1988, Pamela’s gluten-free Chunky Chocolate Chip cookies satisfy thanks to their oversized chocolate chunks and a traditional chocolate chip cookie taste. They’re also free of peanuts, tree nuts, coconut, egg, soy, and dairy. They’re so good, it’s hard to eat just one!

14. Carol’s Cookies Chocolate Chip Mini Cookies

The ordinary will never be the same with this classic sensation. Carol’s brings excitement back to America’s favorite cookie flavor with rich, semi-sweet chocolate in a soft, buttery dough loaded with vanilla flavor. Don’t forget the tall glass of cold milk to wash them down.

FAQ

What is the most popular store-bought cookie in America?

Did you think the best-selling cookie in the cookie aisle was Oreos? Or did you think it came down to a battle of Chips Ahoy vs. Famous Amos? Surprise! That distinction belongs to private label cookie makers. Independent bakers sell more than $1.5 billion worth of cookies every year. 

That’s a lot of cookies. 

These are often specialty bakers, making treats for people on gluten-free diets, those who need peanut or other allergen-free treats to bring to school, want a high-protein snack, or are looking to support local, small, independent businesses. There are even bakers who operate using a charitable model. 

With so many options, there’s no excuse not to enjoy a delicious chocolate chip cookie. 

What brand has soft chocolate chip cookies?

There’s just something about soft chocolate chip cookies that make them so good. Maybe it’s the fact they don’t crumble when you dip them in milk? Or is it because their texture is more of a cross between a cookie and a brownie? Whatever it is, they’re delicious and popular.

So, who can you turn to for a delicious chewy chocolatey treat? Grandma's Big Chocolate Chip Cookie is perfect for the oversized cookie appetite. If you’re looking for something a little more virtuous, you can go with Made Good Organic Chocolate Chip Soft Baked Mini Cookies, a lower sugar option with as many nutrients as a serving of veggies. Shh… We won’t tell if you won’t. Of course, you can’t go wrong with the big two, Chips Ahoy! Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies and Keebler Soft Batch Chocolate Chip Cookies. These have the same great taste you expect from these classic brands, just chewier. 

But don’t take our word for it. Gather the troops and taste test them all to crown your household’s Best Soft Chocolate Chip Cookie Winner.

What is the average number of chocolate chips in one cookie?

That depends on the manufacturer, and they are somewhat tight-lipped on the matter. Chips Ahoy is the only cookie company we could find that has gone on the record to state how many chocolate chips each cookie has.

Back in the 1960s, cookie maker Nabisco promised that each Chips Ahoy cookie would contain at least 16 chocolate chips. That amount was increased to 32 to keep up with the competition but decreased to 24 chips in the 1980s. Since then, Nabisco has promised that each package of cookies would contain at least 1000 chips.

This claim was put to the test by a group of third-graders from North Carolina in 1996. They wrote to the company that their Chips Ahoy package contained only 680 chips. The outrage! Nabisco got right on it and held a public recount. They found that the students had only counted the chips on the cookie’s surface, but once the interior chips were taken into account, Nabisco was vindicated. The count stood at 1,181. 

Promise kept.